get involved button

 

What's Left?

This was the question we used to frame our discussions in July, 2007. It gre from a shared feeling that there was an absence of effective resources for countering the dominant rationalities of our time. This is a feeling that is shared across the political left and is a particular problem in a climate where planning and related issues are once again high on the political agenda. "What's left?" can be understood as a project aimed at developing critical analysis of the state we're in, exploring the pessimism of our collective intellect.

There is a need for discussion and debate about the current state of planning, joining up to wider questions about the state of the world, and planning's position within it. PNUK should become a focus for that discussion, linking to other projects and campaigns that share an interest in challenging the injustices and inconsistencies that sustain the neoliberal order of things. This project must seek to discover the contradictions within that order, and therefore to analyse the bases from which alternatives might spring. It must also provide the bases for acting and responding to the challenges of the current conjuncture.

The idea is to build and maintain a se of useful resources. If you have something to contribute get in touch through the mail list or wiki.

Work towards this will include:

Critical think-pieces on current events/ developments in planning and related fields trying to help us to understand the political moment. (including perhaps distillations of research into accessible think pieces for those without access). These can be anything from a paragraph on a recent news story to a more thought out piece of research. The key is to generate the resources for discussion.

Collecting Resources to help deconstruct the conventional wisdom:
o An annotated bibliographies with links to downloadable articles etc.
o A disorientation guide for students, similar to the one produced by PN in North America
o Resources for campaign groups/ support for them

Research agendas: analysis of the gaps in research that might help to develop a better understanding of where we're at.

An attempt to develop analyses that we can promote through various media

Debates: the event in September 2007 on New Labour and Planning could be billed as the first pnuk debate. If further events are taken forward as discussed on land tax, and housing market renewal this can hopefully become a regular pnuk activity. These can allow discussions to move from being virtual to face-to-face and perhaps become the basis for publications, and other publicising.

Discussion and analysis of emerging policy: including power-points to support practitioner presentations, resources to help people frame responses to consultations.

This is only intended as an indicative list. Anything anyone wants to contribute helps. People taking forward research or other work in areas of particular interest are encouraged to share it through pnuk. All of this is of course work in progress, and we're working from a standing start. If you are interested and feel that pnuk is a worthwhile project then your time and energy will be very much appreciated in helping us take this forward.


 

: What's left? resources

: Roger Levett presented an excellent critical deconstruction of the flawed logic behind both last year's Barker review and the current white paper during our meeting in Sheffield in July. Download the presentation, or read Roger's analysis of the Barker review for the CPRE here.

: Download Cliff Hague's presentation on the international challenges facing planners from our Sheffield meeting here.

: Prof. Patsy Healey has kindly given us permission to include the speech she gave upon receiving the rtpi gold medal here. Download it here.

For analyses and resources including downloadable articles on the current White Paper visit our wikipage.

Mark Brown from The Land is Ours has passed on an article entiteld 'rural policy, rural communities and the planning system' by David Alexander that was originally published in the November 2006 issue of Town and Country Planning. It is available to download as a word file here with thanks to both Mark and David, and also Nick Matthews, editor of Town and Country Planning.

: a collection of what's left links will appear here soon.